Menu of MayLynn's Creamery Boonsboro in Lynchburg, Virginia, USA

Menu Overview

MayLynn's Creamery Boonsboro in Lynchburg, VA, is a charming ice cream destination that stands out with its thoughtfully crafted menu and inviting atmosphere. Located conveniently on Boonsboro Road, this spot offers more than just a sweet treat; it delivers an experience marked by quality, variety, and community warmth.

The menu highlights immediately catch your eye, particularly the Cookiewich, a delightful handheld creation that marries fresh-baked cookies with creamy ice cream, creating a nostalgic yet fresh flavor combination. Equally compelling is the Dipped Ice Cream Cone, which adds a satisfying crunch and extra sweetness to their ultra-smooth ice cream. MayLynn’s also adds a whimsical touch with flavors like Cotton Candy and the luscious Marshmallow Cream, both showcasing a playful approach to classic ice cream enjoyment.

The soft-serve selection reinforces their commitment to quality, with options like the Free Flattop Stamp and varying sizes from small to large, including the notable SS STANLEY. Each offering features the trademark smooth and creamy texture that customers rave about. For those who prefer hand-dipped options, the menu delivers an appealing lineup of Stackers under the Sluggo’s brand, including indulgent choices like Chocolate Cherry Stacker, Butter Crunch, and the fun Cookie Monster Stacker. The ability to Create Your Own Sluggo’s Stacker offers a personalized twist, perfect for adventurous palates.

Customer reviews consistently highlight the friendly, attentive staff and the thoughtfully designed space. The outdoor seating area with games provides a welcoming environment that encourages lingering and socializing. One loyal visitor, Sonya Carden, praises their cheesecake stack with graham cracker crumbs and whipped cream, a rich and decadent choice that speaks to the inventive dessert options available.

From an experiential perspective, MayLynn's Creamery successfully balances a family-friendly vibe with sophisticated flavors and quality ingredients. Its soft serves are exceptionally creamy, and the hand-dipped ice creams are nothing short of indulgent. While occasional operational hours issues have been reported, the overall reputation is built on consistently satisfying sweet cravings and exceeding expectations.

In summary, MayLynn’s Creamery Boonsboro is more than just an ice cream shop — it’s a community favorite and a culinary treat. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick chocolate/vanilla swirl or sinking your teeth into a custom Sluggo’s Stacker, you’ll find that every visit brings warmth, charm, and excellent flavors worth savoring.